So I figured I’d try out the new meme. Go get a list of the top 100 songs from your High School graduation year, and strike through the ones you wish had never been written. If you don’t know, or don’t care about a song, leave it as-is. Note the good ones (done here via italics, ooh).
Too Close, NextThe Boy Is Mine, Brandy and MonicaYou’re Still The One, Shania Twain- Truly Madly Deeply, Savage Garden
How Do I Live, LeAnn RimesTogether Again, JanetAll My Life, K-Ci and JoJoCandle In The Wind 1997, Elton John— fuck the royals.Nice and Slow, Usher- I Don’t Want To Wait, Paula Cole — don’t remember it
How’s It Going To Be, Third Eye Blind— would that I could strike this twice.No, No, No, Destiny’s ChildMy Heart Will Go On, Celine DionGettin’ Jiggy Wit, Will SmithYou Make Me Wanna…, UsherMy Way, UsherMy All, Mariah CareyThe First Night, MonicaBeen Around The World, Puff Daddy and The Family- Adia, Sarah McLachlan
- Crush, Jennifer Paige — don’t remember it
Everybody (Backstreet’s Back), Backstreet BoysI Don’t Want To Miss A Thing, Aerosmith— I remember wondering how they were not dead yet.Body Bumpin Yippie-Yi-Yo, Public AnnouncementThis Kiss, Faith Hill- I Don’t Ever Want To See You Again, Uncle Sam — don’t remember it
Let’s Ride, Montell Jordan- Sex And Candy, Marcy Playground
- Show Me Love, Robyn — don’t remember it
A Song For Mama, Boyz II Men- What You Want, Mase
- Frozen, Madonna — only for the video, like every other Madonna song, ever 😉
- Gone Till November, Wyclef Jean
- My Body, Lsg — don’t remember it
- Tubthumping, Chumbawamba — this one is a tough call, as it’s rancorous vapidity turned me off of the otherwise great band for three years.
- Deja Vu (Uptown Baby), Lord Tariq and Peter Gunz — don’t remember it
I Want You Back, ‘N Sync- When The Lights Go Out, Five — don’t remember it
- They Don’t Know, Jon B. — don’t remember it
Make Em’ Say Uhh!, Master P— doing his best to make sure you never listen to Hip-Hop.Make It Hot, Nicole Featuring Missy “Misdemeanor” Elliott and Mocha— ditto- Never Eve, All Saints — don’t remember it
I Get Lonely, Janet- Feel So Good, Mase
- Say It, Voices Of Theory — don’t remember it
- Kiss The Rain, Billie Myers — same
Come With Me, Puff Daddy— naw, I’m goodRomeo And Juliet, Sylk-E Fyne— took me a while to remember how much I hated this one.It’s All About Me, Mya and SisqoI Will Come To You, Hanson— Wait, you mean Taylor Hanson is a guy!? (watch Family Guy if you don’t get it)One Week, Barenaked Ladies- Swing My Way, K.P. and Envyi — don’t remember it
- The Arms Of The One Who Loves You, Xscape — don’t remember it
- My Love Is The Shhh!, Somethin’ For The People — don’t remember it
- Daydreamin’, Tatyana Ali — don’t remember it
- We’re Not Making Love No More, Dru Hill — don’t remember it
Semi-Charmed Life, Third Eye Blind— I learned the term “heavy rotation” because of this one- I Do, Lisa Loeb
- Lookin’ At Me, Mase — don’t remember it
Looking Through Your Eyes, LeAnn Rimes- Lately, Divine
Quit Playing Games (With My Heart), Backstreet Boys- I Still Love You, Next — don’t remember it
- Time After Time, Inoj — don’t remember it
- Are You Jimmy Ray?, Jimmy Ray — No, but I also don’t remember it
Cruel Summer, Ace Of Base— I remember this one because I was wondering how they were still on the radio, since they sucked in 93.I Got The Hook Up!, Master PVictory, Puff Daddy and The FamilyToo Much, Spice Girls— could I strike the whole group from the record? Please?- Ghetto Supastar (That Is What You Are), Pras Feat. Ol’ Dirty Bastard and Mya — I still can listen to this one
- How Deep Is Your Love, Dru Hill Featuring Redman
- Friend Of Mine, Kelly Price — don’t remember it
- Turn It Up [Remix] / Fire It Up, Busta Rhymes
- I’ll Be, Edwin McCain — don’t remember it
- Ray Of Light, Madonna
- All For You, Sister Hazel — don’t remember it
- Touch It, Monifah — don’t remember it
- Money, Power and Respect, Lox
- Bitter Sweet Symphony, The Verve
- Dangerous, Busta Rhymes
Spice Up Your Life, Spice Girls— no thanksBecause Of You, 98 Degrees- The Mummers’ Dance, Loreena McKennitt — don’t remember it
All Cried Out, Allure Featuring 112- Still Not A Player, Big Punisher Featuring Joe
- The One I Gave My Heart To, Aaliyah
- Foolish Games / You Were Meant For Me, Jewel — don’t really like it, but at the time I was still stuck on the yodelling
- Love You Down, Inoj — don’t remember
- Do For Love, 2Pac
Raise The Roof, Luke- Heaven, Nu Flavor — don’t remember
- The Party Continues, Jd
Sock It 2 Me, Missy “Misdemeanor” Elliott Featuring Da Brat— the start of the comeback of “t[o,w]o = 2”Butta Love, Next- A Rose Is Still A Rose, Aretha Franklin
4 Seasons Of Loneliness, Boyz II MenFather, LL Cool J- Thinkin’ Bout It, Gerald Levert
- Nobody’s Supposed To Be Here, Deborah Cox
- Westside, TQ
So out of the 100, I have decreed that 48 of them should be stricken from the record. Of the remaining 52, I only actually remember 11 (and gave up typing). Of those 11 that I remember and don’t hate, only 2 are actually good songs.
So yeah, either I’m way to critical, or music in 1998 just sucked that bad. I was on a record-geekish, “my tastes are smarter than your tastes, so fuck you and your tongue-in-cheek ‘trailer trash’ hat” phase, but look at that list. The best stuff on it is from 2Pac’s safehouse in Seatt, erm, archives and Dru Hill. When Dru Hill is responsible for the best song of your year (and it’s not even really a contest), you should figure out how bad pop music sucks. Thank god for “Classic Rock” stations, which were on a Led Zepplin/Jimi Hendrix/Doors/Janis Joplin kick (perhaps sensing the obvious market for music that doesn’t suck ass).
Of course, this was particularly noticible to me at the time, having first gotten interested in pop music thanks to Digable Planets’ Rebirth of Slick and grunge. In spite of the retreaded “I can be Ozzy from the 70s” sound, shotgun willie and friends still kicked the shit out of anything on that list.